Have been reading this thread and the previous one ever since it started. Our most recent trip was in November and of course there were lots of changes from our previous trips.
The magic will probably always be there for me. But as someone who only gets to go to WDW about every 2 years, some of the changes are maybe more apparent to me than to those who see them coming on gradually. But then maybe those who go twice a year see more because they have time to look.
For me the changes have simply made the parks smaller. We do fewer lands at MK, take less time now to do Studios and AK, spend more time in Epcot and particularly World Showcase, and repeat our favorites more often.
We totally skip some attractions. But some are sooooo magic and remind us why we love Disney World in general.
The magic has lessened. We have been going to WDW since 1982. It isn't all good. But it's the only place we repeatedly go on vacation and always look forward to the trip. We make the most of it.
So, which car??? If I have to choose, it would be 2. But I have hopes.