ive never been to jellyrolls so i cant say for sure, but based on whhat i have heard i am really looking forward to trying it out! it seems like it is a really good place to go so you may want to go there. However, where you only have one night you may want to go to pleasure island where you have the ability to move around from place to place ...i know the answer doesnt help much and im sure someone will come along who can give you more insight to both areas but im sure whichever you choose will be an enjoyable night out