I prefer Pop too. I have stayed at both AS Music and POP within the past 6-8 months and believe POP is a stronger, more solid choice. I prefer the bus system at POP. At AS Music you share some buses with the other AS resorts and on more than a few occasions the buses were full after their first stop at AS Sports. POP has the benefit of the Generation Gap Bridge & its a plus to walk over to the AoA cafeteria, to wander that resort to see the landscaping and particularly to be able to take advantage of the AoA buses if they show up first for transportation back from the parks at night. I found POP's layout to be more practical and intuitive. AS Music has a longer footprint so it can be a longer walk to and from the further bldgs such as Country Fare, Broadway & Rock. While AS Music has a beautiful fountain area & a fun, themed pool, POP seemed to be in better repair . . . especially the outside lighting at night. I noticed more blown lights and darker areas at AS Music in February. AS Music has just had renos done to its food court. However, I find I eat 99% of my meals in the parks and there are still a few (but only a few!) unique POP food items that I still enjoy. The King Cupcake and the (now sad, little) tie-dye cheesecake. POP is where I'm heading next fall. I've stayed at POP a number of times and personally prefer top floor, 50s section, lakeview. Sometimes I catch a partial view of fireworks at night from my window. While it is a bit longer walk to the food court and buses, I find it is generally quieter in that area. Good luck with your choice! ps check out the large POP resort thread on this board. It has lots of helpful info that may make a difference to you and your family.