Tart N Tinys. The original ones that were something sort of like SweetTarts, not the current candy-coated abomination. And passion fruit Snapple.
I accidentally rediscovered that one of the past (I thought) products I really missed wasn't actually gone, just not stocked in my area - CK One cologne, which was my go-to in high school and college but then seemed to disappear. I was so happy to stumble across it in a fragrance shop on one of our trips, and now it is back to being my go-to when I want a fragrance that's a little more lasting/noticeable than my everyday essential oil scents.