All Star Sports....very poor house keeping. When we stayed there, my dad found a receipt form over a year previous under the bed in their room. There was more to the story, but suffice it to say that Disney has sent me a letter valid for two nights in two rooms at any value resort with no expiration date on it. That should give an idea of how bad it really was.
Does Sports have the worst reputation of the All Stars? Or is that Music?
It would be the Swan/Dolphin for me. I just don't like the resorts and they don't fit in with the New England themed YC, BC, and BW. Also, they ruin the sightlines in World Showcase at Epcot.
I guess I don't have enough experience with the other resorts to give a real good answer for this question, but OUCH - if it weren't for FW I would never be able to afford to take my family to WDW. Thank God it's there. I am sorry if it's offensive to some, but it's the only option for us!