Ok, a new twist: I realized I read the site wrong and it's GF that was way pricey that night, whereas Poly is just ("just," LOL) $100 more than Contemporary. So of course now I'm thinking Poly is the one that meets all the criteria of a fun and entertaining pool, relaxing yet magical post-cruise vibes, and near 'Ohana. I'll sleep on it, especially since it would be nice to try somewhere new since we've already done the Poly as a family in 2022. But with Contemporary being not THAT much more affordable and less appealing, I wonder if we should just go back to our fave!