Some drives on video game systems and PCs have a tendency to scratch discs that are put in them. Not really sure why, but it happens a lot.
And it's not money down the drain. Most electronics stores sell stuff that will remove minor scratches from discs for only a couple bucks.
It may also be a problem with the laser in your 360. How old is your system? And has it played everything else fine since this happened?
Get BioShock Best Game Ever Way Better Than Rock Band.