Would You Stay at Grand Floridian? Beach Avoidable? No Parent Bashing Please!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have stayed at the GF multiple times. The splash pad is a considerable distance from the lagoon edge. There is a large beach, and then a large paved walkway before you get to the splash pad. There are 2 pools, and the central ( very large) pool is no where near a beach. I have been staying here since 1990 and I have been to the beach there once for about 15 minutes, it was hot and pointless. You would not be missing a thing if you avoid the beach completely. I love this resort, and feel very safe. The pool areas are well lit, and almost always very populated. My policy has always been to stick with the light and pavement when on vacation, no matter where I am. Too many creepy crawly unknown things in the dark.

I would 100% feel safe staying at this resort again. It truly is a magical resort

I hope this helps.

I would MOST DEFINITELY stay in Disney's Grand Floridian Resort.

I live in Miami, Florida and very close to beaches and the Atlantic ocean. When I go to WDW, I find those man-made beaches pointless too. Personally, I go no where near them, I wouldn't even considering sticking my pinky toe into one!

However, I understand how guests visiting WDW from a landlocked state or country may desire the feel of a beach and having somewhere cool and breezy to sit while watching their kids play, watching a movie under the stars, or watching fireworks, and while totally being enthralled in the "perfect moment" sadly become oblivious to the dangers.
 
Last edited:
Honestly - I have such young kids that I don't think I would. There are so many other great resorts at Disney. Why introduce a risk even if its very small?

With the exception of AKL, every other Disney resort is adjacent to some form of fresh-water waterway (lake, canal, etc.). Perhaps Disneyland in downtown Orange County California would be more your speed.
 
I posted this on another thread...seriously think about what happened....A BABY IS DEAD. I am not saying not to stay there but I can honestly say I don't know if I could. To be reminded of this tragedy every time you walk by the beach might be too much. For me at least. I pray for those poor parents and hope they can eventually heal from this.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you people not get that 2 parents watched an alligator snatch their 2 year old BABY!!! Knowing there was basically no chance he would survive? Imagine how scared that poor child was while in that alligators mouth. Who cares whose fault it is!!!! It CAN'T happen again! If it is on Disney property it is their responsibility....plain and simple. A BABY IS DEAD! And parents watched it happen! They will relive this moment in their heads EVERY HOUR OF EVERY DAY for the REST OF THEIR LIVES! Could of, should of, would of - a baby is dead. Period. Disney needs to correct the situation to ensure it doesn't happen EVER AGAIN.

Imagine if it was you....and you read the comments on here. Seriously - show some compassion for someone else's grief. A BABY IS DEAD. Disney is a multi-billion dollar company....they will do what is right....regardless of what is said on here.

I am going to go cry now for these poor parents and siblings that lost a child in a most horrible way....a horror story burned into their minds for the rest of their lives. Disney life will go on....unfortunately for this family it will not work that way.

Candice1873, Today at 8:40 AM Edit Report
 
Just a few thoughts for everyone who says they will no longer go to Disney or stay at the grand Floridian because of this tragic accident...do you no longer fly any airline because planes have had tragic accidents or drive cars because of tragic accidents etc ?
 
Just a few thoughts for everyone who says they will no longer go to Disney or stay at the grand Floridian because of this tragic accident...do you no longer fly any airline because planes have had tragic accidents or drive cars because of tragic accidents etc ?
It is a truth that people respond disproportionately to various threats.

People won't let their kids play outside because of stranger danger, but the most likely people to harm your children are known individuals. And everyone is far more likely to die in car crashes than by terrorist action in the US. Fatalities for 2014 alone by vehicular crash are higher than total domestic terrorist fatalities for 2001-2014.
 
I posted this on another thread...seriously think about what happened....A BABY IS DEAD. I am not saying not to stay there but I can honestly say I don't know if I could. To be reminded of this tragedy every time you walk by the beach might be too much. For me at least. I pray for those poor parents and hope they can eventually heal from this.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you people not get that 2 parents watched an alligator snatch their 2 year old BABY!!! Knowing there was basically no chance he would survive? Imagine how scared that poor child was while in that alligators mouth. Who cares whose fault it is!!!! It CAN'T happen again! If it is on Disney property it is their responsibility....plain and simple. A BABY IS DEAD! And parents watched it happen! They will relive this moment in their heads EVERY HOUR OF EVERY DAY for the REST OF THEIR LIVES! Could of, should of, would of - a baby is dead. Period. Disney needs to correct the situation to ensure it doesn't happen EVER AGAIN.

Imagine if it was you....and you read the comments on here. Seriously - show some compassion for someone else's grief. A BABY IS DEAD. Disney is a multi-billion dollar company....they will do what is right....regardless of what is said on here.

I am going to go cry now for these poor parents and siblings that lost a child in a most horrible way....a horror story burned into their minds for the rest of their lives. Disney life will go on....unfortunately for this family it will not work that way.

Candice1873, Today at 8:40 AM Edit Report

Certainly, we all GET it!! We all mourn that loss, and are heartbroken for that family, as well as for all other terrible tragedies that have been happening recently and past, but life must go on.

Not staying at the GF will not keep you from seeing that beach, unless you 'never' go to the MK again, or ride the monorail. I will always be reminded of this one tragedy in 'many' ways, not just its connection there.
 
Are you constantly reminded of the people who have died on rides, the monorail, been run over by buses, etc when at Disney?

That said, Disneyland is quite lovely. My kids prefer it to wdw and it actually has more rides in just 2 parks than wdw's 4 parks so if you can swallow the idea that there may be an earthquake on your Disney vacation, check out gator free California!
 
I wouldn't hesitate to stay at any Disney resort. Like pointed out this was a freak accident and while very sad I don't think that we can avoid every location that has had such occurrences.
 
It sounds as if the OP has their info on where the splash pad and other amenities are in relation to the beach.

We were just there (GFV) for a reunion and GayDays. Without hesitation I would stay at GFV again. By the time I would be able to return for our next vacation, I wouldn't be surprised if some new environment was built to prevent folks from wandering into the ripples of the waters edge. Even if it appears as it does now, without barrier, I would still not only stay there, but I would consider Ft. Wilderness campground where I wouldn't be on a GFV 4th floor "overlooking" the nature amoungst which I'd tent. I understand the concern, and we'd simply exercise what caution we think of to muster wherever we go around the resorts and parks.

Best wishes for your vacation!
 
We have stayed twice before and I would stay again in a heartbeat. What happened was a horrific tragic accident, but I don't think it takes away from the beauty of that resort. (in no way do I mean that to be insensitive) The Grand Floridian is a beautiful and magical resort. That being said, anything can happen anywhere or at any of the other resorts. I think you have be careful and be aware. Unfortunately, it's situations like this and tragedies like this that make us pop out of our comfort zone and make us super aware of everything around us.
 
Just a few thoughts for everyone who says they will no longer go to Disney or stay at the grand Floridian because of this tragic accident...do you no longer fly any airline because planes have had tragic accidents or drive cars because of tragic accidents etc ?
There are some risks that we still must take in daily living...BUT do we HAVE TO take our families to a NAMED Terrorist Target: WDW? I think I'd rather be safe than sorry. If I was unaware of the threat and something happened; I'd be able to live with that. I just can't knowingly fly my family down to one of the most likely places in America to be targeted by the next terrorist. Disney will address this treat; but right now it's simply not safe.
 
We stayed there last year and we never went near the beaches and never even really had to walk by them. Honestly I didn't even see them, lol. We stayed in a pool view room and we were in the building that was between the main pool and the splash pad. Even though I have young kids we honestly didn;t even go to the splash pad bc my kids were happy just being at that main center pool. Would I stay there again? More than likely not, but not because what happened but because the style of the resort just didn't appeal to us. We however LOVED the Contemporary and would stay there again in a heartbeat. Although for our next trip our top resort choice is AKL...we will see which resort we choose after the packages are released next week.
 
There are some risks that we still must take in daily living...BUT do we HAVE TO take our families to a NAMED Terrorist Target: WDW? I think I'd rather be safe than sorry. If I was unaware of the threat and something happened; I'd be able to live with that. I just can't knowingly fly my family down to one of the most likely places in America to be targeted by the next terrorist. Disney will address this treat; but right now it's simply not safe.

Since your tag line says one month, three weeks and five days till your next vacation....are you now not going because you think it is not safe ? Assuming you are talking about a trip to Disney
 
I would not avoid it out of safety concerns. But if I thought it was going to interfere with my happiness, then I would definitely book somewhere else. It doesn't matter if it is reasonable or not--if it bothers you, it bothers you. I wouldn't take my kids on a cruise until my youngest was 6 because I had an unreasonable paranoia about a toddler climbing the rails and going overboard. I knew I would never relax and stop worrying about it. Maybe this is the same thing for you.
 
Since your tag line says one month, three weeks and five days till your next vacation....are you now not going because you think it is not safe ? Assuming you are talking about a trip to Disney

That's the countdown from around 2008.
 
There are some risks that we still must take in daily living...BUT do we HAVE TO take our families to a NAMED Terrorist Target: WDW? I think I'd rather be safe than sorry. If I was unaware of the threat and something happened; I'd be able to live with that. I just can't knowingly fly my family down to one of the most likely places in America to be targeted by the next terrorist. Disney will address this treat; but right now it's simply not safe.

I think my point of view is pretty different from yours.

For the past 15 years, I've taught way too many kids who lost a father or mother or brother or aunt or uncle or grandparent through terrorism. Those people went to work at the World Trade Center on a day in September and were lost. Many of the kids I've taught were too young to even be aware of the loss at the time.

And I've gone to so many student funerals since I first began teaching. There was Deirdre, who was on TWA fight 800 when it exploded over eastern Long Island a few minutes after taking off from JFK. And Mary, who died of CF two months after graduating from high school. And two girls from the school I was teaching in when the van they were driving in was hit by a train as they rushed home to make curfew. And Timmy, who threw his body over that of his girlfriend as their car approached a tree on a stormy night; she survived. And far, far too many others. We lost a Senior this year who went to bed a happy healthy 17 year old, woke up a few hours later with a blinding headache, and died a few days later of an aneurysm.

It's, hands down, the worst part of teaching: the realization that we never know what's to come.

I've learned that there is no place to hide from danger, be it in the form of an act of terror or an act of nature or an accident. I can't wrap my students or my own children in bubble wrap. So we're aware of our surroundings, we try to stay safe, and we live our lives.

WDW isn't a new target for terrorism. It, like the Superbowl and a million other places where people gather by the thousands, has always been on the radar of those who would do us harm because what we believe differs from their beliefs. As, as we saw again last weekend, it doesn't have to be a big, high profile target to hurt each of us to the core.

I agree-- you should probably not go to WDW. And I mean this sincerely, as I would say it to a friend. Your mindset is different from mine, and you would probably worry too much to enjoy your vacation.

But we're keeping our plans to go to WDW next month. We'll take as many precautions as we see reasonable-- and I'm a pretty timid person when it comes to danger. But we'll go.
 
Last edited:
I think my point of view is pretty different from yours.

For the past 15 years, I've taught way too many kids who lost a father or mother or brother or aunt or uncle or grandparent through terrorism. Those people went to work at the World Trade Center on a day in September and were lost. Many of the kids I've taught were too young to even be aware of the loss at the time.

And I've gone to so many student funerals. There was Deirdre, who was on TWA fight 800 when it exploded over eastern Long Island a few minutes after taking off from JFK. And Mary, who died of CF two months after graduating from high school. And two girls from the school I was teaching in when the van they were driving in was hit by a train as they rushed home to make curfew. And Timmy, who threw his body over that of his girlfriend as their car approached a tree on a stormy night; she survived. And far, far too many others.

I've learned that there is no place to hide from danger, be it in the form of an act of terror or an act of nature or an accident. I can't wrap my students or my own children in bubble wrap. So we're aware of our surroundings, we try to stay safe, and we live our lives.

WDW isn't a new target for terrorism. It, like the Superbowl and a million other places where people gather by the thousands, has always been on the radar of those who would do us harm because what we believe differs from their beliefs. As, as we saw again last weekend, it doesn't have to be a big, high profile target to hurt each of us to the core.

I agree-- you should probably not go to WDW. And I mean this sincerely, as I would say it to a friend. Your mindset is different from mine, and you would probably worry too much to enjoy your vacation.

But we're keeping our plans to go to WDW next month. We'll take as many precautions as we see reasonable-- and I'm a pretty timid person when it comes to danger. But we'll go.

Very well stated!
 
I posted this on another thread...seriously think about what happened....A BABY IS DEAD. I am not saying not to stay there but I can honestly say I don't know if I could. To be reminded of this tragedy every time you walk by the beach might be too much. For me at least. I pray for those poor parents and hope they can eventually heal from this.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you people not get that 2 parents watched an alligator snatch their 2 year old BABY!!! Knowing there was basically no chance he would survive? Imagine how scared that poor child was while in that alligators mouth. Who cares whose fault it is!!!! It CAN'T happen again! If it is on Disney property it is their responsibility....plain and simple. A BABY IS DEAD! And parents watched it happen! They will relive this moment in their heads EVERY HOUR OF EVERY DAY for the REST OF THEIR LIVES! Could of, should of, would of - a baby is dead. Period. Disney needs to correct the situation to ensure it doesn't happen EVER AGAIN.

Imagine if it was you....and you read the comments on here. Seriously - show some compassion for someone else's grief. A BABY IS DEAD. Disney is a multi-billion dollar company....they will do what is right....regardless of what is said on here.

I am going to go cry now for these poor parents and siblings that lost a child in a most horrible way....a horror story burned into their minds for the rest of their lives. Disney life will go on....unfortunately for this family it will not work that way.

Candice1873, Today at 8:40 AM Edit Report

I respect your opinion, but if I followed your line of thinking I wouldn't be able to go a lot of places where a child was killed by something senseless - I live in Chicago.

It happened to that family, it didn't happen to you. The real grief and pain is theirs, not ours, we'll be fine by next week if not today - we don't need to be reminded a baby has died, we all know that, that's why there is such a discussion in the first place.
 
Would we stay at the GF? Not even for free! Between this horrible incident and the fact that WDW was scouted very recently as a terrorist attack destination; I plan to keep my family out of harm's way and away from Disneyworld.
are you staying away from churches, schools, malls, movie theaters, courthouses, airplanes, subways, trains, concert halls, nightclubs and social services offices, too? Those have all been targets of terror attacks. It can happen anywhere, without notice (that's the point of terrorist attacks).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

GET A DISNEY VACATION QUOTE

Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.

Let us help you with your next Disney Vacation!











facebook twitter
Top