Jr's Cheesecake in NYC.
I wanted 3 things, a NY slice, Junior's Cheesecake, and Katz's Pastrami sandwich. I had high expectations for the pizza, which was delicious but no different than pizza in the mall. I had low expectations of the cheesecake because I am very particular about how cheesecake is in consistency and flavor. I thought no way is it as good as people say and I was blown away. In fact, I just found out for my birthday, someone ordered through mail a Junior's Cheesecake for my birthday in a couple of weeks, exciting! LOL. I had also that year ordered a Junior's for my daughter's birthday 2 years ago (which was a sampler with all the stuff on top and the mail person left it on my porch on it's side. Still cold with dry ice packs but all the toppings had run off. I was more than furious as it was a very expensive purchase. Still delicious though.)
We didn't make it to Katz. I hope we can someday make another trip and get a Pastrami sandwich.