It's amazing that 2 e ticket rides that are opening in 3 weeks have no definative height requirments. Again it seems like everyone has a different story.
The only "everyone" I would believe is anything directly from Disney.
Is Al Lutz reliable, because he also said the racers would be 40 inches, not 42. It should not be this difficult getting info on height requirments. Especially when Disney raises prices and people who are on the fence whether to plan a trip and bear those crowds, it might make a difference. Those 2 rides are highly anticipated and if a parent knows there kid can't ride, they wont go.
As for your Al question, sometimes yes, sometimes, no. He does not work for Disney. He is reporter. I never really understand why we so heavily discuss it rantings on this site, but always keep in mind he is part of the media, period.
As for the "Official" information - it is possible that Disney has not had the final safety check from OSHA which has the final word on height requirements.
As for planning a trip, I guess my thoughts are, there is sooooo much more to see, do, and experience than just those two rides. If they are the only thing making you contemplate visiting or not, I would not visit. That's a LOT of money to simply experience two rides. I don't know that I agree with "if a parent knows [their] kid can't ride, they won't go." I would hope people go for much more than just two rides, for their own experience.
I can't understand why Disney would make a place like Cars Land, that little kids love, and then make the rides such that little kids can't ride. Where is the sense in that? Or would Disney do it to attract adults? I wonder...
There are various rides throughout both Parks that "kids can't ride." Not everything has to be centered around the littlest kids. Disney is for everyone, not just the littlest of kids. There is a lot of sense in making rides that are geared towards older kids and adults, as long as there is a mix. That's what makes EVERYONE love Disney, not just little kids.
- Dreams