O.k, I've said it before that I'm opinionated...
My husb. & I SPECIFICALLY sail
DCL because we always (until now) have felt that we can trust Disney to have guidelines in place on the ship & island to make sure that things are kept "Disney clean". That not only pertains to comedic performances, shows, ship upkeep, etc., but also to appropriate dress on the ship - including the pools & on the island.
Someone mentioned that women 'don't want their husb. seeing'. That's not the case for all women. I'm in my very early 40's (told I'm thin & attractive) but have NEVER found scantily clad women or men in public tasteful - even as a kid. There is a time & a place for everything & out in public is not the place!
I don't agree with those who make excuses for others such as "they may be from another country where it's acceptable" - they're NOT in THAT country. Or, "who deems what is 'appropriate'". I would imagine that the majority of people that 'go Disney' - & esp. those with children with them - feel that appropriate attire is not seeing boobs, genitals or rear ends hanging out for the world to see. Those who are sailing DCL & doing this belong on the other ships where gambling, a lack of strict attire, lots of boozing, etc. is acceptable.
When we checked into the 7-nt & found that some of the beaches could possibly have nude bathing, we knew it wasn't for us & decided to stick w/the 4-nt. That is OUR compromise. Now, to hear that CC could possibly be like every other public beach - that is depressing. Just wanted to have a fun, Disney-clean cruise.