I would like to help you figure this out but alas, i can't find any availability at CBR to let me price it out. Did you add in the dining plan cost to turn it into a "ticket-less package" to let you compare apples - to- apples? OR did you just do the cost of the room and then rough estimate of what you would order? Not sure what you're seeing happen, BUT if the discount you already have is better than this, just keep it!
CBR from Dec 11 - 24 is $2751.24 and 8 day park passes are $607.06. Those two alone will be $3358.30.
Free Dining package costs me around $4200 (we're adding more park days, but haven't done that yet, so don't know the exact $$). So that will be roughly $840.70 left for food.
If we were to add "ticket-less"
DDP for $63.70 per person then $3358.30 + $1656.20 = $5014.2, which will be $800 more than FD.
And FD includes WPFAM, which we don't really want, but oh well.
So, if I do the calculation differently, say that I spend about $55 per adult per night. (say we eat A LOT at the buffet dinner and eat small for lunch)
That will be $55 * 2* 13 = $1430 + $607.06 (tickets) = $2037.
Difference $4200 - $2037 = $2163 for either Disney Resorts or stay outside.
Disney Resorts, I can do Value resort for that price range, but not moderate.
If staying outside, then I have to deduct parking fees ($160), car rental for 2 weeks ($280), Gas ($50) leaving me $1673 for the hotel. 128.70 per night tax, resort fee, included.
But if I were to spend $$ on dining as I would with dining plan, then $1673 go down to $1450-ish.
Is there any error in my calculation, please advise me. Thank you!